Saturday, September 7, 2013

POLICE CHECKPOINTS IN NIGERIA: Mitigating the excesses by the Men in Black





Thought provoking prompts:
At every single point in time, the sight of the Nigeria Police on the roads should at every point in time usher in a feel of relief, peacefulness and the assurance that one's life and properties are well protected.
But incidentally, the contrary is what obtains a number of times in Nigeria, with many ultimately calling for the absence of police checkpoints on the road.
The reason for this is due to the many abuse of such call on duty by the Men in Black (Not Will Smith and Tommy Lee Jones in the movie) comprising the bribery and extortion of motorists, notably the public transport operators; the shooting of innocent people and the unprofessional approach to pulling over vehicles or causing traffic jams and at times, accidents in a bid to arrest erring motorists.
These cases too many, some of which would be highlighted in the course of this work is the basis for this article.
On this note, the police checkpoint, a tool long employed by the Nigeria Police Force to combat and control the flow of crime across the board is one widely considered to be inefficient, as it has been employed as a chameleon to them (the police) committing crime as mentioned earlier.
No wonder the cancellation of the checkpoints in March 2012 by the Inspector General (I.G) of Police, Mr Mohammed Abubakar, then in acting capacity, was greeted with relief by many.  The then disclosure (in 2012) by the I.G. that the removal of the police checkpoints had saved Nigerians about 6.43tn comprising police extortion, losses and time management only brings to conclusion that the road blockage in itself was an inefficient tool to combating crime in the country. 

In his words, the I. G said “Even when the checkpoints were in place, how many kidnappers did they stop? How many vehicles or persons involved in smuggling of arms and ammunition or robbery on these roads did they stop? Rather, what they were doing was tarnishing the image of the police by involving themselves in embarrassing acts.”

Obviously, these image tarnishing acts entail bribery and extra judicial killings which I believe can be checked, after all one does not fight crime by running away from it but confronting it with rigid and ugly measures.

But interestingly, in a bid to avoid these image tarnishing vices via the cancellation of the checkpoints, what comes to mind are the more efficient substitute in place to combat the free flow of crime on the road.

Fine the I.G mentioned the employment of many patrol vehicles and a strengthened communication amongst the police personnel but what I opine must first come to mind before its cancellation are

·         every country has different approaches to committing crime, dependent on its crime history, size, capacity and nature of crime regularly committed;

·         the availability of social amenities like good road networks;

·         the availability of modern technology, notably the Closed Circuit Television (CCTV), which is a nitty gritty and substitute to putting away the Men in Black from the roads, as it aid the tracking of human and vehicular movements within the coverage of its strategic placement; and

·         the regularity of patrol by the squad cars and vans, which in itself is very cost intensive in the long run.

The absence of one or all of these is a NO to stopping the checkpoints, as it would put crime on a rise.

From the aforesaid, it is not surprising that the cancellation of the checkpoints was a sojourn call, as the Men in Black are back on the streets. 





The image on the right makes one statement, the Return of the Men in Black to the checkpoints








Too many incidents with unanswered questions:
Notable examples which have long brought to mess the existence of police checkpoints include the killing of one Emmanuel Victor, a 20-year-old young adult at a checkpoint in Yenagoa, Bayelsa State on October 16, 2011, for allegedly condemning the extortion and bribery at the checkpoint by three policemen on duty < http://www.punchng.com/news/bayelsa-checkpoint-killing-parents-sue-police-for-n200m/>
Other stories include the painful killing on June 13, 2013 of nine year old Timilehin Ebun by some policemen while trying to extort money from a commercial bus whom in a bid to evade giving the Men in Black money (a bribe), had them opening fire on him, which sadly was a stray shot that pierced through the Ebun family’s SUV, killing the young Timilehim, with other family members inside the vehicle. < http://www.punchng.com/news/police-stole-our-joy-father-of-slain-boy/>.

Not forgetting the 2009 killing of a three year old girl, Kasufara Muritala, also at a checkpoint by former police corporal, Ikechukwu Nwabueze < http://www.punchng.com/news/court-sentences-police-corporal-to-death-for-killing-three-year-old-girl/>; the fatal accident caused by some policemen while trying to arrest a commercial motorcyclists, aka Okada, for driving against traffic <http://www.punchng.com/news/container-truck-crushes-man-govt-meat-van/> and drawing the curtain to these painful losses and disregard for human life is the September 20, 2012 killing of Ugochukwu Ozuah, barely five days after his wedding. Ozuah was killed while dropping his friend whom paid him a courtesy visit off < http://www.punchng.com/news/police-accused-of-killing-man-five-days-after-wedding/>. Sadly in this case, like many others, in a bid to save face, the police denied responsibility of a handful of these killing, owing it to armed robbers. Sadly, the list is endless.

These stories cited are too many incidents with many unanswered questions, questions that are only answered by a better equipped, oriented and high frequency in there-facing of the Nigeria police



 





An image of a “raised eyebrow” police checkpoint in Nigeria which is unnecessarily crowded with cops. Having 6 cops on car indeed makes the checkpoints congested.





 
 



 




  A better organised checkpoint with a cop per car during routine check.








Checking trigger happiness and other excesses by the Nigeria Police:


In checking the trigger happiness by the cops, so much have to be done which should be well monitored by not just the cops but the public, as the public are in the best position to have a fair check, as against the police, whom are known to cover-up.

First of all, there is need for the police to regularly orientate and re-orientate its personnel on what to consider, with respect to positioning, and location before pulling vehicles over. This is pivotal preventing avoidable accidents or gridlocks.

Secondly, there is need for the police to call the attention of the public on its check points locations across the federation. This would be achieved through the social media and e-
platforms, especially twitter. This serves the advantage of putting the public better informed  on legal checkpoints, thus identifying the illegal ones which are most times planted by armed robbers.

Also, through regular adverts and campaign across the various media networks (print, electronic, social and e-media), as this would have the public better aware on the need to pull over or obey the police whenever such call arise because some motorists are fond of flouting in this respect, not parking when asked to by being motionless on the road.

Thirdly and very importantly, the police should keep the public informed on the the need to pull over on checkpoints as against fleeing such checks. On this note, huge sanctions should be metted to such individuals and the police should keep the public informed of such fines.

Regular communication with the public of checkpoints location and re-orientation of the police achieves:

·         A drop in fear that such checkpoint could be planted by armed robbers. This is due to the fact that many citizens have falling victim to feigned checkpoint planted by armed robbers,  whom while being a chameleon in checking cars, carry out their evil acts;

·         On the flip, the encouragement of the public to keep the police informed of illegal police checkpoints or any deemed strange to them which is not included in the lists provided by the police.    

·         Keeping the police more conscious to be professional and not aggressive in the discharge of their duties because they are known to be very rude and harsh which does not speak well for them. And it will have them closely monitored by the public.  

On  a fourth note, every police formation and area should be held accountable for checkpoints planted within its jurisdiction. The advantage this serves is that whenever cases of extra judicial killings arise, the area or formation where such killings arise would be held accountable, averting the frequency of denials exuded by the police, as everyone would know where to point a finger at.

More so, whenever there is a change in checkpoint location, the public should be informed. The employ of the social media would no doubt be a speedy approach to achieving this. 

Still on the social media, each police formation in every state should be mandated to independently have its social media page/platform, precisely twitter for the public to follow in order to be promptly and regularly informed of the activities by the police. No questioning one thing, this singular act would on a wide scale keep the public better abreast with the activities of the police, draw the police closer to the people with its efficiency ultimately achieved and the truly being the friend of the public. 

Most importantly is the encouragement to the police for giving their lives to fight crime. They are widely known to be poorly paid and the effectiveness of take home pay in relation to ones job is expedient to achieve the required drive of one to perform, especially when it is a job with one putting one’s life on the line. 

In achieving an efficient police checkpoint, it is imperative for the police to have an effective checkpoint to checkpoint communication to discourage vehicles from fleeing when asked to stop, as they would have it on the back of their minds that resisting a check is a waste of time, after all they would be caught by subsequent checkpoints. 

No doubt, the strategic placements of these checkpoints is very very imperative.

With the April 16, 2013 report by the Punch, Nigeria < http://www.punchng.com/news/reps-probe-police-extra-judicial-killings/> on the call by the Nigerian lower legislative chamber, House of Representative’ directive of an investigation into rising cases of extra-judicial killings by the police, the points noted in this article would greatly contribute in making the extra judicial killing a thing of the past, as anyone could be a victim, you just never can tell until it happens.

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

THE 2013/14 FOOTBALL SEASON ACROSS EUROPE (PART 2): The mathematical approach to being a clairvoyant on the CONTENDERS





                                                                                                       

 

                                                                                               



 



With the 2013/14 season having an average of 4 matches played across the major leagues in Europe, notably Spain, Germany, Italy, England and France, permit me to say that the million dollar question on the mind every follower of the beautiful game in these leagues is who the CHAMPIONS would be, in addition to the teams to dominate these leagues, courtesy having a top half table finish and instrumentally, a top 4/5 finish.  

This article is expected to follow the trend built by the inaugural edition of the series, "The Contenders Rating Scale (CRS)" which kicked of in the 2012/13 football season, http://taiwokehinde-mymind.blogspot.com/2012/08/the-20122013-football-season-contenders.html

Contenders Rating Scale (CRS)  is a mathematical approach to predicting a minimum of the 3 teams that would have a top 5 finish in the major leagues across Europe. Please note that for the purpose of this work, every team in consideration would be referred to as the Contenders and interestingly, with the CRS, you don’t have to guess the final team placement in your favourite league in vain, as the CRS would be your guide and of course, get you being a clairvoyant in this respect. 
Here are some useful links on the success of the Contenders Rating Scale in the 2012/2013 season:
With the success achieved, courtesy the aforementioned links, it is expected that the 2013/2014 season would be no different, as it would be an efficient tool in predicting the final table placement outcome in these leagues.

We would begin with the German Bundesliga, whilst providing a step by step approach to RIGHTLY predicting the final top 5 teams. 
Contenders Rating Scale (CRS): How it works!
In arriving at the final 5 teams in the respective leagues, the top 5 teams in the last 5 years would be closely examined and their cumulative scores, being the determining factor in making the cut to the CONTENDERS TABLE.
Mathematically, below is a guide to exude how the CRS works:
 1. The top 5 teams in each of the last 5 years (seasons) "2008/2009, 2009/2010, 2010/2011, 2011/2012 and 2012/2013" will be considered for selection as the  Contenders.
2.  In analysing the last 5 years thereby paying attention to the top 5 teams in these years, a 5 mark (point) scale will be used to credit the teams based on their final league table placement in each of these years as stated in step 1.
3. Having rated these teams, the overall total mark scale will be obtained by summing up the yearly mark scale of these clubs based on the number of times they had a top 5 finish and subsequently the final league placement in each of these years would be the major determinant at arriving at the overall mark scale.
From the 'afore-guide’, with the marks summed up, the 5 teams with the highest marks will make up Contenders Table.
With  respect to guide/step 2, the below refers:
The 1st placed teams will have 5 marks (mks)

The 2nd placed team will have 4 mks.

The 3rd placed team will have 3 mks.

The 4the placed team will have 2 mks.

The 5th placed team will have 1 mk.

In this edition of the Contenders Rating Scale (CRS), we would kick off our illustration with the German Bundesliga, while the French Ligue 1, English Premier League, Spanish La Liga and Italian Serie A would all be respectively touched on.
THE GERMAN BUNDESLIGA: Top 5 at a Glance

 Below is the CRS of the German Bundesliga:



 TABLE 1:        2008/2009 GERMAN BUNDESLIGA (YEAR 1)

















TABLE 2:         2009/2010 GERMAN BUNDESLIGA (YEAR 2) 
















TABLE 3:         2010/2011 GERMAN BUNDESLIGA(YEAR 3)
















TABLE 4:         2011/2012 GERMAN BUNDESLIGA (YEAR 4)















TABLE 5:         2012/2013 GERMAN BUNDESLIGA (YEAR 5)

















From the 5 tables above, it is noticed that cumulatively,  11 teams were in the top 5 position, at one season or the order. This is detailed in the table below dubbed "The "Contenders  Table"


TABLE 6: THE GERMAN BUNDESLIGA CONTENDERS TABLE 



















From these 11 teams, the teams with the top 5 cumulative grade points (expected top 5 finishers of the 2013/14 season in the Bundesliga) are Bayern Munich, Borussia Dortmund, Bayer Leverkusen, Schalke 04 and VFL Wolfburg.

It imperative you note that the table above does not illustrate the order of final placement of these teams at the end of the season and a minimum of 3 teams are expected to make the cut.
 
Lastly, I predict that either/both Stuttgart and Werder Bremen would replace the 2/1 team(s) that may fallout from the final table placement. 

*The top 5 teams closely expected, my league CHAMPION in the German Bundesliga would be Borussia Dortmund. 


THE FRENCH LIGUE 1: Top 5 at a Glance

The French Ligue 1 Contenders Rating Scale would follow the same sequence of the German Bundesliga earlier illustrated.

In a similar fashion, the 5 years to consider in determining the teams to have a top 5 finish are the 2008/09; 2009/10; 2010/11; 2011/12 and the 2012/13.

Kicking the tabular history would be the 2008/09 season subsequently illustrated below:


  
TABLE 7:        2008/2009 FRENCH LIGUE 1 (YEAR 1)














TABLE 8:         2009/2010 FRENCH LIGUE 1 (YEAR 2) 















TABLE 9:         2010/2011  FRENCH LIGUE 1 (YEAR 3)
















TABLE 10:       2011/2012  FRENCH LIGUE 1 (YEAR 4)

















TABLE 11:       2012/2013 FRENCH LIGUE 1 (YEAR 5)
















From the 5 tables above, it is noticed that cumulatively,  11 teams were in the top 5 position, at one season or the order.

Like earlier illustrated in the German Bundesliga, "The "Contenders  Table" in the French Ligue 1 is shown below:


TABLE 12: THE FRENCH LIGUE 1 CONTENDERS TABLE 
















From the Contenders Rating Scale table above, it is observed that Marseille, Lyon, Paris Saint Germain and Lille respectively had 17, 15, 11 and 11 cumulative points.

However, catching our attention would be Montpellier and Bordeaux tied with the same cumulative points and placed in 5th and 6th place.

Due to this tie, the CRS in the French Ligue 1 would pay attention to the top 6  teams in which 4 of them (Marseille, Lyon, Paris Saint Germain, Lille, Bordeaux or Montpellier) is predicted to have a top 6 finish at the end of the season.

Importantly, with 2 of these teams not making the cut, I project that newly promoted side and big money spenders,  AS Monaco would have a significant finish (top 6) at the end of the season (pushing fellow big spenders and current holders of the French Ligue 1 title, Paris Saint Germain), all the way by finishing in second place. Interestingly, I will not be surprised if Monaco displaces PSG and win the 2013/14 season – remember you first heard this from me when it happens.

THE ENGLISH PREMIER LEAGUE: Top 5 at a Glance

Following the train in this clairvoyant touch to knowing the minimum of three teams to have a top 5 finish in the major football leagues across Europe is the English Premier League (EPL).

In a similar fashion, the 5 years to consider in determining the teams to have a top 5 finish are the 2008/09; 2009/10; 2010/11; 2011/12 and the 2012/13 seasons in that order.

 TABLE 13:      2008/2009 EPL (YEAR 1)
















TABLE 14:       2009/2010 EPL (YEAR 2) 















TABLE 15:       2010/2011  EPL (YEAR 3)















TABLE 16:       2011/2012  EPL (YEAR 4)















TABLE 17:       2012/2013 EPL (YEAR 5)















From the 5 tables above, it is noticed that cumulatively,  8 teams were in the top 5 position, at one season or the order. This is detailed in the table below dubbed "The "Contenders  Table":



TABLE 18: THE ENGLISH PREMIER LEAGUE CONTENDERS TABLE











Interestingly, with regards to the English Premier League only 8 teams recorded a top 5 finish in the last 5 years.

In focus, a minimum of 3 of Manchester United, Manchester City, Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspurs would have a top 5 finish, come the end of the 2013/14 season.

Be reminded that the order in which these teams are arranged in the CRS, is no illustration of their final league placement order.

Next in focus is the Italian Serie A, following the trend of the earlier discussed leagues.

*My take on the League Champion would be Arsenal but no doubt, there would be a little or a very insignificant change to the title contenders, as notably Manchester United and Chelsea would push them all the way.

THE ITALIAN SERIE A: Top 5 at a Glance


 TABLE 19:        2008/2009 ITALIAN SERIE A (YEAR 1)

















TABLE 20:       2009/2010 ITALIAN SERIE A (YEAR 2) 















TABLE 21:       2010/2011 ITALIAN SERIE A (YEAR 3)
















TABLE 22:       2011/2012 ITALIAN SERIE A (YEAR 4)

















TABLE 23:       2012/2013  ITALIAN SERIE A (YEAR 5)














From the 5 tables above, it is noticed that cumulatively,  11 teams were in the top 5 position, at one season or the order. These teams are found in the table below:

TABLE 24: THE ITALIAN SERIE A CONTENDERS TABLE 












  



The  Italian Serie A has AC Milan, Juventus, Inter Milan, Napoli and Udinese paving the way in the Contenders Rating Scale, entailing that a minimum of 3 of these teams would have a top 5 finish at the end of the 2013/14 Italian Serie A season.

*Juventus would win the league for a third consecutive time is my expectation, though I consider Napoli to push them to the very end for the title, while either or both Milan sides (Inter and AC Milan) would have a significant finish.


THE SPANISH LA LIGA: Top 5 at a Glance

 
Lastly, the Spanish Primera Liga would be our touchdown in the Contenders Rating Scale analysis which would be no different from the earlier treated leagues, as the same steps would be closely implemented.
In similar fashion, subsequently illutsrated are the 2008/09; 2009/10; 2010/11; 2011/12 and 2012/13 seasons.

 TABLE 25:      2008/2009 SPANISH  PRIMERA LIGA (YEAR 1)















TABLE 26:       2009/2010  SPANISH  PRIMERA LIGA (YEAR 2)
















TABLE 27:       2010/2011 SPANISH  PRIMERA LIGA (YEAR 3)
















TABLE 28:       2011/2012 SPANISH  PRIMERA LIGA (YEAR 4)















TABLE 29:       2012/2013 SPANISH  PRIMERA LIGA (YEAR 5)















From this 5 reference tables, it is observed that cumulatively, the Contenders Rating Scale of the Spanish Primera Liga had 9 teams ceiling a top 5 finish at one season or the other. 

These teams are tabularised below:

TABLE 30: THE  SPANISH LA LIGA CONTENDERS TABLE














From the Contenders Table above, a minimum of 3 of Barcelona, Real Madrid, Valencia, Sevilla or Atletico Madrid are expected to have a top 5 finish in the 2013/14 La Liga Season.
With an average of 3 matches played in the aforementioned leagues, these projections wrapped up on September 3, 2013 would no doubt get you all exuding your clairvoyant skills.

*Barcelona is where I will put my money on, though as usual and always, the league title would be a two-horse race between the defending champions, Barcelona and Real Madrid.

These closely followed, I bet the final table placement of the 2013/14 season is well anticipated with a view to knowing the efficiency of the Contenders Rating Scale.


Watch out for the 2013/14 Mid-Season Contenders evaluation across the board on this blog This is projected to be published in January 2014.